Many brands launch expensive ad campaigns without knowing if they'll work. In 2024 alone, CPG companies invested over $48 billion in digital ads—much of it spent on untested creative. Without creative pre-testing, brands risk wasting millions on campaigns that fall flat.
First impressions matter—and getting them right can make or break a campaign. Brands must balance creative innovation with proven effectiveness, all while competing for consumer attention that grows more scarce each year.
In this article, we'll explore how brands can use creative pre-testing to validate their campaigns before launch. We'll look at the testing methods that top companies use, examine real case studies of successful creative optimization, and reveal the key strategies that lead to better performance. Whether you're running global campaigns or product-specific ads, you'll learn how to test and improve your creative using data-driven insights.
Focus groups and surveys were once the primary ways to test advertising. These methods worked, but they were slow and expensive. A company might spend months and thousands of dollars testing an ad campaign, only to get results after the campaign had already launched. Even worse, many brands still rely on in-market testing—running ads live and waiting to see what works, essentially using their media budget to test.
This reactive approach costs brands twice: first in wasted ad spend on underperforming creative, then in the time and resources needed to fix problems after they occur. Marketing teams can't afford this trial-and-error method anymore. They need to know what works before spending their media budgets.
Modern creative pre-testing tools, like Swayable, use the same methods that scientists use in medical research. These tests, called randomized controlled trials, measure exactly how ads affect what people think and do. This removes the guesswork from creative decisions.
These randomized controlled trials allow marketing teams to validate their creative before launching campaigns, spotting and fixing potential problems while ads are still in development. By employing these scientific methods, brands can save money in two critical ways: first, by avoiding investment in ineffective ads, and second, by targeting the right messages to the right audiences.
Marketing teams can now test their ideas quickly and get clear answers about what works. They can show different versions of their ads to real people and measure how these ads change opinions about their brand or make people more likely to buy their products. This approach enables teams to experiment with different creative approaches, identify the most promising concepts, and ensure that their final ads are more likely to succeed.
WATCH: How DoorDash Uses Creative Pre-Testing To Change Hearts & Minds
Research shows that creative elements contribute to 47% of a campaign's success—making it the single biggest factor in advertising effectiveness. To maximize this potential, marketing teams must approach creative pre-testing with a strategic and comprehensive measurement approach.
Meaningful measurement goes beyond simple metrics. Marketing teams track how their ads influence brand perception, purchase intent, and message recall across different audience segments. This involves a holistic approach that combines quantitative metrics with qualitative insights. With Swayable, for instance, numbers reveal how many people responded positively to an ad, while detailed feedback explains why people were (or weren't) persuaded by the creative.
The most effective teams know exactly what they want to measure before testing begins. Common goals include improving brand sentiment, increasing purchase likelihood, and understanding how different audience groups respond to their messaging. By testing rough versions of ads early, teams can catch and fix issues when they're still inexpensive to change, ensuring the final creative is optimized for maximum impact.
New Balance, the athletic wear company, wanted to improve how they tested their advertising. They needed to know if their ads would work, but their old testing methods took too long. The company took an agile approach and teamed up with Swayable to conduct rapid creative pre-testing for all their marketing, from big brand campaigns to ads for specific shoes. This new approach changed how they created their ads as well as who they targeted with ad spend.
"Having a test go live on a Friday and being able to share those results back on a Monday has been really important for us. We've done creative testing in the past, but through longer processes like Kantar reporting and brand health tracking on a quarterly basis. Being able to test something and have answers back within a matter of hours or a couple of days has been incredibly valuable," says Lauren Riker, Global Marketing Manager at New Balance.
This quick testing helped New Balance make better decisions about their advertising. They could check if their messages connected with audiences before creating expensive final versions. They also learned which audiences liked their ads most, helping them show their ads in the right places.
When companies spend billions on digital ads, the ability to predict and perfect campaign performance isn't just helpful—it's essential for survival. Traditional advertising methods of guesswork and reactive testing are no longer sufficient when consumer attention is increasingly scarce and expensive.
Creative pre-testing offers a scientific, data-driven approach to advertising that improves how marketing teams develop and launch campaigns. By using randomized controlled trials and advanced testing tools like Swayable, brands can now validate their creative before spending millions on potentially ineffective ads. Companies like New Balance demonstrate that rapid, strategic testing can lead to more impactful advertising and more efficient budget allocation.
The most successful marketing teams now understand that creativity and data are not opposing forces, but powerful allies. They combine innovative ideas with rigorous testing, checking concepts before committing significant resources. This approach allows them to create ads that not only look good, but deliver measurable results—connecting with audiences, changing perceptions, and ultimately driving business growth.